Protein benchmark systems

Protein benchmark systems

This page enumerates benchmark systems for assessing the accuracy of protein force fields and tracks which individuals or groups are responsible for running each benchmark simulation. Benchmark systems are organized into tiers with increasing complexity for each tier.

In the tables below, short name is the string used to identify the benchmark target in the proteinbenchmark repo here:

. Type is one of peptide, folded, or disordered and is used to determine the default solvent padding and simulation length. For the folded type, the CATH domain classification (https://www.cathdb.info/wiki) is provided in parentheses. Starting model is either extended or a PDB ID. N residues is the number of protein residues. N solvated atoms is the total number of atoms (protein+water+ions) in the solvated system.

Tier 1 (rapid evaluation)

Target name

Short name

Type

Starting model

N residues

N solvated atoms

Simulator

Target name

Short name

Type

Starting model

N residues

N solvated atoms

Simulator

Trialanine

ala3

Peptide

Extended

3

1409

@Chapin Cavender

Tetraalanine

ala4

Peptide

Extended

4

1824

@Chapin Cavender

Pentaalanine

ala5

Peptide

Extended

5

2614

@Chapin Cavender

Hexaalanine

ala6

Peptide

Extended

6

3680

@Chapin Cavender

Heptaalanine

ala7

Peptide

Extended

7

4848

@Chapin Cavender

Triglycine

gly3

Peptide

Extended

3

1430

@Chapin Cavender

Trivaline

val3

Peptide

Extended

3

1400

@Chapin Cavender

Gly-Ala-Gly

gag

Peptide

Extended

3

1427

@Chapin Cavender

Gly-Glu-Gly

geg

Peptide

Extended

3

1409

@Chapin Cavender

Gly-Phe-Gly

gfg

Peptide

Extended

3

1395

@Chapin Cavender

Gly-Lys-Gly

gkg

Peptide

Extended

3

1401

@Chapin Cavender

Gly-Leu-Gly

glg

Peptide

Extended

3

1409

@Chapin Cavender

Gly-Met-Gly

gmg

Peptide

Extended

3

1407

@Chapin Cavender

Gly-Ser-Gly

gsg

Peptide

Extended

3

1425

@Chapin Cavender

Gly-Val-Gly

gvg

Peptide

Extended

3

1409

@Chapin Cavender

Tier 2 (select release candidate)

Target name

Short name

Type

Starting model

N residues

N solvated atoms

Simulator

Target name

Short name

Type

Starting model

N residues

N solvated atoms

Simulator

Ace-(AAQAA)3-NH2

aaqaa3

Disordered

Extended

16

26733

@Chapin Cavender

Bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor

bpti

Folded (4.10.410.10)

PDB 1PIT

58

10899

@Chapin Cavender

Streptococcal protein G third immonuglobulin-binding domain

gb3

Folded (3.10.23.10)

PDB 1P7E

56

7668

@Chapin Cavender

Hen egg white lysozyme

hewl

Folded (1.10.530.10)

PDB 1E8L

129

16787

@Chapin Cavender

Human ubiquitin

ubq

Folded (3.10.20.90)

PDB 1D3Z

76

14741

@Chapin Cavender

Tier 3 (assess release candidate)

Target name

Short name

Type

Starting model

N residues

N solvated atoms

Simulator

Target name

Short name

Type

Starting model

N residues

N solvated atoms

Simulator

Amyloid β (1-40)

ab40

Disordered

Extended

40

291473

Alpha-synuclein

asyn

Disordered

Extended

140

7333819

 

NESG target CcR55

ccr55

Folded (3.20.170.20)

PDB 2JQN

116

14194

@Lily Wang

NESG target CtR148A

ctr148a

Folded (3.30.70.260)

PDB 2KO1

88

27180

@Lily Wang

NESG target DhR29B

dhr29b

Folded (2.170.120.30)

PDB 2KPU

96

45762

@Lily Wang

NESG target DhR8C

dhr8c

Folded (2.60.40.2000)

PDB 2KYI

161

17793

@Julianne Hoeflich

NESG target ER382A

er382a

Folded (2.30.30.100)

PDB 2JN0

53

7149

@Julianne Hoeflich

NESG target MrR110B

mrr110b

Folded (2.40.50.140)

PDB 2K5V

269

20815

@Lily Wang

NESG target PsR293

psr293

Folded (3.90.1150.30)

PDB 2KFP

125

33612

@Lily Wang

NESG target SR478

sr478

Folded (6.10.140.40)

PDB 2JS1

80

45881

@Lily Wang

NESG target SrR115C

srr115c

Folded (1.25.40.10)

PDB 2KCV

99

14547

@Julianne Hoeflich

NESG target StR65

str65

Folded (1.20.1290.30)

PDB 2JN8

110

21860

@Lily Wang

NESG target XcR50

xcr50

Folded (3.40.30.10)

PDB 1XPV

78

10709

@Julianne Hoeflich

Small molecule physical properties

This section describes physical property calculations run using OpenFF Evaluator or OpenFE Pontibus rather than the proteinbenchmark repo.

Target name

Type

Ligand FF

Water model

Simulator

Target name

Type

Ligand FF

Water model

Simulator

Mixture densities/enthalpies

Small molecule

OpenFF 3.0.0 alpha0

TIP3P

 

Mixture densities/enthalpies

Small molecule

OpenFF 3.0.0 alpha0

OPC3

 

MNSol

Small molecule

OpenFF 3.0.0 alpha0

TIP3P

MNSol

Small molecule

OpenFF 3.0.0 alpha0

OPC3

FreeSolv

Small molecule

OpenFF 3.0.0 alpha0

TIP3P

 

FreeSolv

Small molecule

OpenFF 3.0.0 alpha0

OPC3

 

Protein-ligand benchmarks

This section describes relative binding free energy calculations run using OpenFE Pontibus rather than the proteinbenchmark repo.

Target name

Type

Protein FF

Ligand FF

Water model

Simulator

Alchemiscale scope

Target name

Type

Protein FF

Ligand FF

Water model

Simulator

Alchemiscale scope

JACS dataset

RBFE

ff14SB OFFXML

OpenFF 2.2.1

TIP3P

@Irfan Alibay

omsf-pontibus_0_2_0-openff_2_2_1_ff14sb_tip3p_*