Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Differences in parameters

Δ_Angles:

...

The maximum delta in the equilibrium angles is 2.95 degrees, and the maximum difference in k value is 37 units, here are the those parameters

Code Block
a36 [#6X3:1]-[#16X2:2]-[#6X4:3]       2.96 deg
a38 [*:1]~[#15:2]~[*:3]              37.06 kcal/(mol rad**2)

...

Code Block
a7   2.30 degrees, change in value    2%       12.35 kilocalorie/(mole*radian**2) , change is    16%
a8  -2.57 degrees, change in value   -2%      -17.33 kilocalorie/(mole*radian**2) , change is   -17%
a9  -0.82 degrees, change in value   -1%      -17.51 kilocalorie/(mole*radian**2) , change is   -19%
a12  -2.47 degrees, change in value   -2%       10.98 kilocalorie/(mole*radian**2) , change is    24%
a13   0.34 degrees, change in value    0%        3.54 kilocalorie/(mole*radian**2) , change is    12%
a33   1.66 degrees, change in value    2%      -24.70 kilocalorie/(mole*radian**2) , change is   -29%
a36   2.96 degrees, change in value    3%       12.29 kilocalorie/(mole*radian**2) , change is    14%
a37  -1.30 degrees, change in value   -1%       19.24 kilocalorie/(mole*radian**2) , change is    16%
a38  -0.87 degrees, change in value   -1%      -37.06 kilocalorie/(mole*radian**2) , change is   -29%

Δ_Bonds:

...

Not much difference, the maximum difference is in the bond length is 0.05 Angstrom, and the maximum difference in k value is 23 units, here are the parameters

...

All of the bond parameter changes are insignificant even in percentages,

Δ_Torsions:

...

Noticeable differences in torsion parameters, here is a list of parameters that show at least 0.5 kcal/mol difference in the k-values

...

[torsion_id, smirks_pattern, difference in k_values list_in_units_of_kcal_per_mol]

Percentage difference in any of the k-values is greater than 50%:

Code Block
breakoutModewide
['t2', '[#6X4:1]-[#6X4:2]-[#6X4:3]-[#6X4:4]', [' 51%', '-11%', '-5%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.09', '0.32', '0.32'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.14', '0.28', '0.31']]
['t5', '[#8X2:1]-[#6X4:2]-[#6X4:3]-[#8X2:4]', ['-428%', '-11%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['-0.03', '0.46'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.10', '0.41']]
['t6', '[#9:1]-[#6X4:2]-[#6X4:3]-[#9:4]', ['-241%', '-10%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.02', '-0.18'], ', Sage refit:', ['-0.03', '-0.16']]
['t10', '[#1:1]-[#6X4:2]-[#6X4:3]-[#9:4]', [' 167%', '-95%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.10', '0.34'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.27', '0.02']]
['t17', '[*:1]~[#6X3:2]-[#6X4:3]-[*:4]', [' 111%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.03'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.06']]
['t18', '[#1:1]-[#6X4:2]-[#6X3:3]=[#8X1:4]', [' 9%', ' 4%', '-112%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.45', '0.15', '0.03'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.50', '0.16', '-0.00']]
['t19', '[#1:1]-[#6X4:2]-[#6X3:3]=[#6X3:4]', ['-9%', ' 200%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.30', '0.01'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.27', '0.02']]
['t21', '[#6X3:1]-[#6X4:2]-[#6X3:3]=[#6X3:4]', [' 713%', ' 60%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['-0.04', '0.17'], ', Sage refit:', ['-0.30', '0.27']]
['t23', '[#6X4:1]-[#6X4:2]-[#6X3:3]-[#7X3:4]', [' 76%', ' 2%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['-0.05', '0.15'], ', Sage refit:', ['-0.08', '0.16']]
['t24', '[#16X2,#16X1-1,#16X3+1:1]-[#6X3:2]-[#6X4:3]-[#1:4]', [' 55%', '-17%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['-0.12', '-0.45'], ', Sage refit:', ['-0.19', '-0.37']]
['t25', '[#16X2,#16X1-1,#16X3+1:1]-[#6X3:2]-[#6X4:3]-[#7X4,#7X3:4]', ['-337%', '-176%', ' 10%', '-33%', ' 32%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.10', '0.10', '-0.73', '0.27', '0.45'], ', Sage refit:', ['-0.24', '-0.08', '-0.80', '0.18', '0.59']]
['t26', '[#16X2,#16X1-1,#16X3+1:1]-[#6X3:2]-[#6X4:3]-[#7X3$(*-[#6X3,#6X2]):4]', ['-86%', '-102%', ' 109%', '-242%', '-149%', '-168%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.36', '0.71', '0.30', '0.38', '0.01', '-0.05'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.05', '-0.01', '0.62', '-0.54', '-0.00', '0.03']]
['t27', '[*:1]-[#6X4;r3:2]-[#6X3:3]~[*:4]', [' 205%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.13'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.41']]
['t29', '[#1:1]-[#6X4;r3:2]-[#6X3:3]~[#6X3:4]', [' 502%', '-44%', '-41%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['-0.04', '-0.15', '0.40'], ', Sage refit:', ['-0.22', '-0.09', '0.24']]
['t31', '[#6X3:1]-[#6X4;r3:2]-[#6X3:3]=[#8X1:4]', [' 4%', '-4%', '-245%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['2.67', '-0.55', '0.32'], ', Sage refit:', ['2.76', '-0.53', '-0.47']]
['t34', '[#6X4;r3:1]-;@[#6X4;r3:2]-[#6X3:3]~[#6X3:4]', ['-99%', ' 21%', ' 4%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.05', '-1.04', '1.38'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.00', '-1.26', '1.43']]
['t35', '[#6X4;r3:1]-;@[#6X4;r3:2]-[#6X3;r6:3]:[#6X3;r6:4]', [' 38%', '-55%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.07', '0.62'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.09', '0.28']]
['t39', '[#6X4;r3:1]-;@[#6X4;r3:2]-[#6X3;r6:3]:[#7X2;r6:4]', ['-6%', ' 158%', ' 38%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['2.57', '-0.29', '1.15'], ', Sage refit:', ['2.42', '-0.74', '1.58']]
['t40', '[#6X4;r3:1]-;@[#6X4;r3:2]-[#6X3:3]=[#7X2:4]', [' 15%', ' 10%', ' 200%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['-0.72', '1.67', '-0.05'], ', Sage refit:', ['-0.83', '1.84', '-0.14']]
['t41', '[#6X4;r3:1]-;@[#6X4;r3:2]-[#6X3:3]-[#8X2:4]', ['-105%', ' 21%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['-0.36', '1.57'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.02', '1.91']]
['t51bh', '[#1:1]-[#6X4:2]-[#7X3:3]-[#7X2:4]=[#7X2,#8X1]', ['-132%', ' 100%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['-0.04', '-0.01'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.01', '-0.02']]
['t59', '[*:1]-[#6X4:2]-[#7X3$(*~[#6X3,#6X2]):3]~[*:4]', [' 5%', ' 133%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.18', '0.03'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.19', '0.07']]
['t64', '[#6X3:1]-[#7X3:2]-[#6X4;r3:3]-[#6X4;r3:4]', [' 96%', '-31%', ' 71%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.91', '-0.97', '-0.81'], ', Sage refit:', ['1.78', '-0.67', '-1.38']]
['t83', '[#7X2:1]~[#7X2:2]-[#6X4:3]~[#1:4]', [' 67%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.05'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.08']]
['t113', '[#6:1]-[#16X4,#16X3+0:2]-[#6X3:3]~[*:4]', [' 56%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.67'], ', Sage refit:', ['1.04']]
['t118', '[*:1]~[#8X2:2]-[#7:3]~[*:4]', [' 107%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['1.02'], ', Sage refit:', ['2.10']]
['t135', '[#6X4:1]-[#16X4,#16X3+0:2]-[#7X4,#7X3:3]-[#1:4]', ['-363%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.47'], ', Sage refit:', ['-1.23']]
['t136', '[#6X3:1]-[#16X4,#16X3+0:2]-[#7X4,#7X3:3]-[#1:4]', ['-54%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['0.17'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.08']]
['t137', '[#6X4:1]-[#16X4,#16X3+0:2]-[#7X4,#7X3:3]-[#6X4:4]', ['-0%', ' 317%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['1.25', '-0.06'], ', Sage refit:', ['1.25', '-0.25']]
['t139', '[#8X1:1]~[#16X4,#16X3+0:2]-[#7X4,#7X3:3]-[#1:4]', ['-115%', ' 28%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['-1.53', '0.16'], ', Sage refit:', ['0.23', '0.20']]
['t154', '[*:1]-[#7:2]-[#15:3]=[*:4]', ['-41%', ' 63%'], 'original params: Sage rc1', ['2.49', '0.43'], ', Sage refit:', ['1.47', '0.70']]

...

Id

param

chemical structure

Residuals

Relative energies

RMSDs wrt QM

18536987

t26

18886218

t26

18886217

t26

18886214

t26

18536986

t26

18886215

t26

18536998

t31

18886228

t31

18536052

t31

18535855

t64

18886290

t64

18537049

t64

18886280

t64

18536071

t64

18045648

t64

18535856

t64

18886474

t118

6098576

t118

18537139

t118

18537138

t118

18886475

t118

18535893

t135

18886517

t135

18886515

t135

2703135

t135

18886530

t139

18536128

t154

Image RemovedImage Added