Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

Excerpt

Constrained fit to initial values.

👀 Overview

Summary

In Approach II, the virtual site charge ~0.17e on the pyridine was regarded as somewhat low. This fit adds a weak charge restraint to initial values for all virtual sites, which primarily affected the pyridine virtual site. This . The resulting charge around 0.3 e did not improve performance on condensed phase properties. In addition, we took a closer look at Br properties, which also showed worse performance. This may be due to a lack of multi-site Br fitting data. In Approach IV we attempted a re-fit with additional data.

GitHub repo/branch

Status

Status
colourRed
titleWon't progress

Table of Contents
minLevel2
maxLevel6
outlinefalse
stylenone
typelist
printabletrue

\uD83D\uDEA9 Milestones and metrics

Stage

Milestone/Benchmark

Contributors

Deadline

Status

Train virtual sites and BCCs to existing HF/6-31G* data, with a weak constraint to initial charge

Re-fit 2.1.0 BCCs and virtual sites to ESP data

Lily Wang

Oct 2023

Status
colourGreen
titleCompleted

Re-fit valence and vdW parameters to condensed phase properties

Re-fit FF terms for vsites-candidate

Dec 2023

Status
colourGreen
titleCompleted

Benchmark

Improved or equivalent performance for molecules with virtual sites added (Cl, Br, pyridines) on training data

Dec 2023

*Note: this was delayed due to an unexpected outage with lilac access.

Status
colourRed
titleFailed

Presentation: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1fQjJn2OfApAmxfSCdxxwPuGveWoS0gPRYZ9MVL32OVk/edit#slide=id.g2a39d07bb62_0_21

📊 Progress and findings

Re-fitting virtual sites with charge restraints

The pyridine virtual site stabilized around 0.3 e:

...

No real effect was observed on the halogens with the restraint:

...

Fitting to condensed phase properties

This change in pyridine charges didn’t appear to substantially affect the condensed phase properties.

...